I recently joined the server (as Kevin_Warde).
Have been gone for a few days (new SSD, reinstalled everything and setup dual-boot w/ linux etc. blabla).
Now I just found this website and I read the rules and I noticed this rule:
- Using name tags sa-mp provide to know someone's name is not allowed.

And yes, off course admins will want to see them, so why not keep the function ShowNameTags() enabled, set for connecting players all nametags to non-show (ShowPlayerNameTagForPlayer) but enable them for admins?

Then, in addition to this suggestion;
What about a function where you have to meet someone? Eg. "/meet [playerid]". After using it, enable nametags for each other.
I think that this might satisfy you (@Luke), and I think it's actuall a rather nice idea.

You can use /nametags to turn the nametags off in general.

About /meet command... I don't think so, we are not claiming ourselves as high-end RP server, unfortunately.